Pomona Philosophy majors are required to take Philosophy 190 in the fall of their senior year during which they produce a literature review (25 pages or more) on a philosophical topic of their own choosing (in consultation with a Faculty Reader). The literature review gives students latitude that they may not have had in their previous coursework. It is very helpful, but not required, if the student chooses a topic that was touched on in a previously taken course.
The literature review summarizes and evaluates the key scholarly literature (of roughly 15 articles, book chapter, or other relevant scholarly literature) on the chosen topic. It should identify what the major ideas in the literature are, how they are related to one another, and the chief strengths and weaknesses of those ideas.
Philosophy 190 is run by a Faculty Instructor who organizes the weekly meetings. Because the Faculty Instructor may have no expertise in the student’s chosen area, each student selects a Faculty Reader with whom to work. The Faculty Reader must be a member of one of the five Claremont Colleges (5C) Philosophy departments and not on sabbatical when you are enrolled in Philosophy 190. The student must choose a topic for which a 5C philosopher is willing to be a reader.
Students should reach an agreement with the faculty member who will be their reader by the end of the Spring Semester prior taking Philosophy 190. The list of scholarly literature students will be reviewing is due at the beginning of Philosophy 190 and thus must be compiled during the summer. Students should consult with their Faculty Reader for advice on locating and selecting the relevant scholarly literature.
Philosophy 190 satisfies the philosophy senior exercise requirement. The literature review can serve as an excellent basis for the optional senior thesis.
For more details, contact the Chair of the Philosophy Department.